Drones Do No Make the World a Better Place
DRONES DO NOT MAKE THE WORLD A BETTER PLACE
In 2001, the United States Central Intelligence Agency tested an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle, or drone, for the first time, when they dropped Hellfire Missiles from a Predator Drone. Since that day, drone warfare has become a widely used weapon for the United States military, especially in Middle East countries like Afghanistan and Pakistan. While many supporters of drone warfare claim that it keeps us safe, the use of UAVs actually make the world more violent and dehumanize people around the globe.
https://www.teenvogue.com/story/obamas-drone-warfare-is-something-we-need-to-talk-about
In order to fight against terrorist organizations, such as Al-Queda, the U.S. has relied heavily on drone tactics. When Barack Obama became President in 2008, he promised to end the war on terrorism. Between June 2004 and October 2012, the United States conducted 334 drone strikes in Pakistan, according to the New American Foundation.
Here are some of the arguments that those in favor of drone strikes use, and why they are false.
1. Drones are useful for killing terrorists while minimizing civilian casualties
One of arguments in favor of drones is that, because of their precision, they can effectively and efficiently kill terrorists without causing civilian casualties. However, the data behind this claim is questionable. First, the US government keeps all the information about their drone agenda classified, never releasing the numbers on how many strikes or killings have taken place (Boyle 5). Michael Boyle, a Senior Fellow with the Foreign Policy Research Institute, wrote in his academic journal, The Costs and Consequences of Drone Warfare, that “No one—among either advocates or critics—really knows the number of deaths caused by drones in these distant, sometimes ungoverned, lands.” Furthermore, the statistics that are released by independent organizations can be skewed, due to the unclear definition of a militant, versus that of a civilian. Media in the US can spin the narrative, because according to a New York Times report, the United States deems all males who are military age in a strike zone as “militants,” thus inflating the number who militant kills and minimizing the civilian kills (Boyle 7). In Madiha Tahir’s investigative film Wounds of Waziristan, she describes this phenomenon, in which investigative journalist Chris Woods calls it “extraordinary” that the US would use this criterion to classify terrorist. Tahir juxtaposes this with images of young orphans who were killed in the drone strikes.
https://www.democracynow.org/2013/11/4/wounds_of_waziristan_exclusive_broadcast_of
Another argument supporting drone warfare is that they succeed at their mission of killing those who are deemed high value targets. Former President Obama was very adamant that the drone attacks were very precise, only killing those who are a threat to the world’s safety. However, since 2004, it is estimated that drone strikes have killed 49 high ranking military leaders, which is only 2 percent of total killings from drone strikes (Boyle 9). This leaves 98 percent of killings to lower ranking officials, who pose speculative danger, not immediate. Also, killing an immense amount of “foot soldiers” has grave effects. David Kilcullen and Andrew Exum write that “every one of these dead noncombatants represents an alienated family, a new desire for revenge, and more recruits for a militant movement that has grown exponentially even as drone strikes have increased.” United States and Pakistani government relations have grown resentful.
3. Drones
put pressure on terrorist organizations, decaying their ability to organize and
attack.
While drone strikes aid in scattering terrorist groups such as Al-Qaeda, they did not neutralize them. As seen in Tahir’s film, drone strikes have caused an outcry, inciting protests against Obama and his foreign policy that resulted in taking innocent lives. And the terrorist groups adapt, themselves. Hundreds of Al-Qaeda member have fled to Yemen, Somalia, and Iraq, bringing weapons and experience along with them. Even in places where the Al-Qaeda presence has decreased, other Islamist groups have filled in their place, such as Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan, who actually establish a stronger danger against the Pakistani government than Al-Qaeda did in the first place (Boyle 11).
https://www.statista.com/chart/20005/total-forecast-purchases-of-weaponized-military-drones/
4. Drones are the better option, morally, compared to the alternatives.
Advocates of drones will often use the reasoning that drones are morally better because the US is not putting lives on the line as they would be in ground combat, or even aerial attacks. In the case of UAVs, they do not have anyone in the vehicle, as it is controlled by those in front of a screen, far away from the battlefield. These people’s lives are not being risked. Plus, in comparison to ground combat, there are far fewer civilian casualties. However, this argument dissolves because the US is using drone warfare in places where they aren’t even at war. Again, drone warfare, when compared to ground combat, is safer, but it is irrelevant to compare drone warfare to alternatives that are impractical, and not even permitted out of the context of war. Truthfully, it is fairer to relate drone strikes to less violent acts like covert operations, or just diplomatic pressure (Boyle 13). Furthermore, while the U.S. tends to grade the performance of its drone strikes by its short-term success, particularly the number of high value target killings, but they tend to neglect the long term effects. In fact, Obama’s heavy reliance on drones has caused a drones race, where several nations around the world are trying to develop their own drone technology. The global spending on drones is estimated to be $94 billion (Boyle 22). With foreign relationship being tense, a “no risk” warfare system can create horrific consequences, especially when it is available to weaker, rebelling nations. As the US sees the success of drones, there are consequences, and at the end of the day, violence will continue to ensue.
Lastly, in Wounds of Waziristan, Tahir attempted to change the narrative, to flip the focus off of the American mission, and really emphasize the humanity of those in Waziristan. Sadly, drone warfare dehumanizes the people that it targets. For the officials controlling the drones, the people they are bombing are just faces on screens. This has a very negative effect on our world. Anytime the dehumanization of other individuals is normalized, it is not good.
Works Cited
Tahir, Madiha. Wounds of Waziristan, Democracy Now, 2013, https://www.democracynow.org/2013/11/4/wounds_of_waziristan_exclusive_broadcast_of. Accessed 2022.
Comments
Post a Comment